AND NOW . . . HERE IS A POST ABOUT STROLLERS!

your heroine and her humble fleet of strollers. taduhhh! is this not ridiculous?

so.... there is no such thing as the perfect stroller. you can write that on my tombstone. 

i used to feel really strongly that i only needed one stroller. i practically gave myself an ulcer trying to decide on THE STROLLER when we were expecting huck, so i could hang my hat on being so very minimalistic and practical. but. there is no such thing as the perfect stroller, we're going to have to reconcile ourselves to that fact right now. we can possibly also agree that probably everybody needs two strollers, but that most likely nobody needs four. 

in my defense! i started out with just one stroller, as i said it was THE stroller or as close to it as we could get and i thought i was pretty swag really (swag is something they say in utah, i'm down with it), and then the volo was given to us when huck was 9 months old and i was like, "revelation!" oh the wonders of good umbrella stroller! then came the uppababy, an impulse second-hand purchase from a friend when she moved, because i was sure i'd be getting pregnant immediately and would need a family-style double stroller STAT (we've been trying to sell it since. you wanna buy it? pretty please?), and then bugaboo sent us the lovely cameleon 3, and... so. it kinda snuck up on me. but one of my girlfriends here in the city has owned over 11 different strollers in the five years she's been a mom, so... well i guess i don't feel that bad.

i can now say i've pushed three of the most commonly spotted strollers in my 'hood, so i figured i'd be all helpful and shizz and write about my experiences with them. whatever. right?

so please to enjoy this bit of a mini exhaustive stroller review that i threw together. putting my bizarre love of over-thinking things to good use or something!

(i've put it after a jump so it doesn't eat up my whole page. you have to click through if only so you can see my mad righteous macintosh paintbrush skills.)


bugaboo sweetly sent me the new cameleon 3 to try out last month. since this is the stroller i've been pushing lately, this is the one we'll start with. and i hate to say it, because the price point is so stratospheric on these suckers, but good gravy, this is a really, really great stroller. we've loved it.

a stroller is a very personal thing and what one person needs in a stroller may be entirely different from the next. for me, the end all be all in stroller specs is a narrow wheel base. store aisles are tiny and sidewalks are packed, and successfully navigating elevators and doorways with one hand while pushing the stroller with the other all hinges on the width of your stroller being not dumb. i cannot do a wide stroller. so even without its impeccable safety ratings, bugaboo had me at its width. it's actually not too much wider than my volo, and that is really saying something! (the volo is kind of my second baby.)

looks are another key for me, since my stroller parking happens to be my entryway and i can see my entryway from nearly every vantage point of my home. you don't want to be looking at a hulking ugly monstrosity all the live long day, and this stroller happens to be one of the prettiest out there. 

the bugaboo handles cracked, bumpy sidewalks and the cobblestone streets of soho really well. switching to the bug after pushing the vo' for the last year was kind of like upgrading from a unicycle to a private jet. though i will say this: the bug is not a stroller for hopping curbs, which i do a lot. it's also awkward and ungainly trying to bump it up or down stairs, which i have to do pretty often. the cushy shocks are marvelous over rough terrain, but the minute you need to pop a wheelie it's like balancing an elephant on your knee. it seems to me like no matter how great your "big" stroller is, you are going to need an umbrella. you will pry my volo from my cold dead hands!

also worth noting is i've had a hard time getting the sunshade to say up and taut when i want it in its fully extended position, though i'm not sure it's not just user error (likely).

all in all, if i were purchasing a new stroller i'd absolutely consider the cameleon 3. in a heart beat. maybe second-hand if new wasn't in the budget.  i mean, it's a private jet.

oh volo my volo! oh how i love my sweet volo!

the only thing i really dislike about this stroller is it doesn't recline (other maclaren models do but they're not as lightweight), and if you overload the handles with bags it'll tip over backwards the minute you look away--sometimes (usually) with your baby in it and then strangers will GASP! and you'll feel like a horrible mom. (luckily maclarens are made so well that nobody will get hurt, i promise. and some kids think it's kind of fun.) eh, it's also not really a great winter time stroller. i do like a heavier duty stroller with a well-fitted foot muff to keep my small person warm. oh, right, and after long days with the volo i usually come home with a righteously sore upper back. the volo is a work out. you should see my biceps!

(i hear the new volo models recline? b and i have been toying with the idea of swapping the volo out for a TRIUMPH, which reclines but isn't as heavy as the TECHNO, once we finally sell the uppababy (no but really do you want to buy our uppababy?.)

yes, my first years! i have deep and abiding feelings for my first years, man. it's the stroller that made me a mother. i did a million hours of research before buying this sucker. here is why we chose it:

we were living in under 400 square feet and needed something that would collapse easily into a very small corner, and it could NOT come with extra parts i needed to store (so, no separate bassinet, for example). the first years seat is both bassinet and toddler seat. it just takes a few clicks of some straps and you're set. magic. done.

performance wise, this stroller is pretty killer for the price. it's hundreds less than any other stroller we looked at, and it looks a lot like the bugaboo and in a lot of ways it behaves very similarly too, though it's not nearly as solid and one of the back wheels likes to click at me sometimes. but it's very pretty . very, very pretty, and well-designed, too. except for the foot brake, which sucks. it gets any slight piece of sand or gravel or dust in it and it stops responding immediately. no bueno. also the storage basket is laughably small.

this stroller also comes with a cool party trick: you can twist a little doohickey on the handlebar and then rotate the stroller seat all the way around. 360 style. like the girl's head in the exorcist. if your baby wants to see you, or your baby wants to stop seeing you and start seeing the world, you can turn him around mid stride. it is seriously the coolest. i used it all the time to keep the sun out of huck's eyes and to check on him while he was napping without having to stop in the middle of a crowded sidewalk. 

oh yeah, and it was CHEAP. brandon keeps pressuring me to sell it but the thing is..... no. honestly if i were to recommend a stroller to anyone anywhere it would be this one here. i love it so. (in fairness, i'm sure if i started using it now after having used the bugaboo the last months i'd be like, "this thing is a piece of crap!")

don't get me wrong! this is an amazing stroller. i just don't need it for what it's best for. i bought the uppababy vista from a girlfriend when she moved to texas because, with the RUMBLESEAT and RIDEBOARD (both of which i also have), the uppababy is a family machine. it's a freaking SUV! i've seen five kids on one uppababy before, no joking. so if you're going to have a lot of kids all stroller age all at the same time, this stroller is perfect for you! but... we're strictly a one baby at a time type family thanks to my dusty baby box, and as a single stroller, well.... as a single stroller i just don't love it. 

my biggest problem with the vista is its width. this sucker is w-i-d-e. sure, this gives the vista an unprecedented amount of space in the undercarriage basket, but who needs that much storage? it's so much space that i start to leave things in there that don't belong just because it all fits and i'm lazy. this stroller is just too dang big.

i also have a hard time with the handlebar extender, which seem to be located exactly where i'll accidentally activate it as often as possible. and because it's so wide, it's hard to maneuver in and out of doorways (though it has excellent steering and is by far the easiest stroller to push one-handed). also, while it's absolutely gorgeous when the bassinet is installed, it (and the STOKKE too) sort of reminds me of a praying mantis once the toddler seat is in?


that's it, you survived! 

p.s. another stroller that's very popular among moms on the upper west side 
(i haven't tried it . . . yet ;) 

78 comments:

  1. we have the first years and looove it. like a whole lot. i miss the days when our little lady fit in the bassinet. i just wish the storage was a bit bigger though. maybe it prevented me from making random slurries while shopping. ;)

    xo, amanda

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. slurries...nonono. i meant splurges, auto correct!

      Delete
  2. We have three strollers, but I wish we had four. We don't have an umbrella stroller, and there are times where it's just perfect! The BOB stroller is a good stroller. We also have a triple stroller which is awesome for some things and lame for others. Actually, a lot depends on which stroller currently has a flat tire, for me.

    ReplyDelete
  3. this proves that i will read absolutely anything written by you just because i love your writing. i have no kids, am not pregnant or trying to get pregnant yet i just read an entire post about the pros and cons of different baby strollers because you are so witty and hilare.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've also just done this! I'm 19!

      Delete
    2. That makes 3 of us. Natalie could probably write about finding a band-aid in Huck's diaper and I'd read. (Though, please don't.)

      Delete
    3. Yep...no babies or interest and just did the same thing. ;)
      But if I was in the market...I'd trust Natalie.

      Delete
    4. And I make 5 in this count of super fans?!

      Delete
    5. Guess I make 6! I'm 22, and an unmarried, unbabied college student. Thanks for the laughs Natalie!

      Delete
    6. I'm 45 with 2 grown kids and absolutely, positively have no desire to have any more kids and I read the whole post. Number 7!

      Delete
    7. 8!!! Haha no kids, not married, not buying a stroller anytime soon!!!

      Delete
  4. We have four strollers too (an umbrella one, a single jogger, a double jogger, and a goes-with-the-car-seat one). You'd think I was out walking or running constantly, but. . .no. Fortunately, they've all been super super cheap (gifts or hand-me-downs or garage sales), so I continue to justify owning them all.

    ReplyDelete
  5. i just figured out that our uppababy allows us to add seats (and a rideboard!) and i'm thrilled (trying for baby #2 soon with a 7 mo old)! our version must be old - or i'm just unaware - because i don't have hand brakes. i love it!

    thanks for the reviews - you're awesome!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. same here! i had no idea mine had handbrakes. going to check now... haha

      Delete
  6. how on EARTH do you fit anything else in your NYC-sized apartment with so many strollers!? do you hang them on the ceiling or what!? lol

    though i don't have kiddos, definitely some things to think about that us not-yet-mothers probably wouldn't consider when picking one out for the first time ;)

    ReplyDelete
  7. This post is a special kind of awesome, We actually didn't have a stroller for our first baby because I wore her everywhere. Oh the minimalism! But the fact was, we just didn't have occasion to use a stroller often enough. Now we've moved, had another baby, and suddenly we NEED a stroller! I was astonished at the devotion Amazon reviewers show for their strollers. I figured out after a while your "no one stroller is best" revelation. We went with the Britax B-agile and as long as I don't have occasion to drive any other strollers I'm going to declare myself happy.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Long-time lurker here, but I could talk about strollers forEVER, so comment I shall. After this, you will probably pray fervently that I return to my non-commenting ways. Seriously, other than breast pumps, what other piece of kid equipment elicits more opinions, wild stories, and the occasional super fierce evangelist for x, y, or z stroller brand. I had no idea, pre-kid, the hours of research required to make this decision, especially if you don't have a car. This thing is your main mode of transit! Your trusty steed!

    Our family specs are thus: 1 year old kid, 4th floor walk-up, no car/daily public transit users, fabulous Chicago neighborhood with horrid sidewalks. The trusty steeds we employ are currently a bugaboo frog (hand-me-down from a friend of a friend, I KNOW) and maclaren techno xt. Now let's be real here: pre-kid, I absolutely and totally judged bugaboo owners for their SHEER EXTRAVAGANCE ... Now I know better. It conquers crappy sidewalks with ease, my kid loooooves napping in it, carries home a surprising amount of groceries in its basket, fabulous winter foot muff, rain cover that fits like a dream, and definitely wins the least-ugly stroller award. Bad things: dreamy rain cover takes up too much space in basket (precious real estate, yo), whole thing is kind of a witch to carry up stairs, or break down and stuff somewhere, NO way you could ever travel easily with this beast, and that damn bassinet basically leaps off the top shelf and onto someone's head any time they reach into our front closet. Speaking of the bassinet, one time I loaded it up with boxes of papers to be shredded and marched it all on over to the shredding place ... but that's about the extent of its usefulness. I take the bugaboo on the bus regularly, but not usually the train, which brings us to ...

    The techno. A recent addition to our family via Craigslist. Yes, it's the heaviest, but only by a couple pounds and that sunshade is insanely awesome and actually functions. Plus, the wheels are almost twice as beefy as the volo or triumph (like I said, crappy sidewalks round about these parts). This is definitely our public transit friendly option, as well as flying/traveling, now that the babe is too heavy to hoof around the airport in the ergo (sob).

    The question in my mind now is doubles. I see way less of them out and about (why?! only crazy people keep on city-livin' with more than 1 kid? or possibly they finally break down and get a car?) so there are fewer opportunities for me to accost their owners and press them for the dirty details ...

    p.s. Nat: from my vantage point, you are fabulous. Thanks for gracing the internets with your presence. It's inspiring to see urban families loving where they live and making it work, nbd. Peace, woman.

    ReplyDelete
  9. i love an umbrella stroller! i walk everywhere. literally. it is easy to get in and out of spaces. but, i'd be lying if i didn't want a stroller that practically self propelled itself and reclines a bit more.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thank you so much! This was super helpful! Did you consider any travel systems when you were doing your stroller research?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i didn't, because we didn't need a car seat when huck was born (we don't have a car!)

      Delete
  11. Wow what a great review! I read it till the end though I happened to have pushed ANOTHER 3 strollers in NYC. The City Mini which I loved: inexpensive, incredibly easy to fold even if you are holding your baby, and super light weight... the con is that it is in the wider base side. Then I had a second baby within 18 months of my 1st one and used the City Select, which I highly recommend though it is super heavy and folds in 2 parts, bur you can have so many arrangements of your two babies: facing you, facing each other, etc; and if you are up to just stroll around, and walk and walk its very good! And finally when my little girl started walking I sold the City Select and got me a McLaren Double Triumph and I'm loving it. All the pros of the Volo (two babies, not as lightweight) but it can be reclined to stroller naps!
    Well, I liked very much the review and I'm passing it to my brother who is having a baby this summer but thought I could add those other strollers in my experience as a NYC mom of two!

    ReplyDelete
  12. We have a Cameleon and I bump it up and down stairs all day no problem...but (bit BUT here) ours is older. It's a 2005 that was given to us when I was pregnant and so it has air-filled tires, whereas all the Cameleons post-2008 have foam filled tires. I think that is the key difference. I LOVE our Cameleon SO much! Could NEVER live without it. It's basically our minivan as we live car-free directly in Zurich city. That said, we do have a Mountain Buggy, too, which my husband uses for running with our daughter. No one can live with only one stroller! ;) The umbrella will be next...

    ReplyDelete
  13. this totally cracks me up. we are pregnant w/ baby #2, and all my "stroller stress" from #1 seems silly now that we have to sell our 3 current strollers (jogger, volo, car-seat carrier)... what a mess! we just bought the hauck freerider- it holds 1-2, comes with a car seat adaptor, is tandem, and you can run with it (well, not all-terrain) for a good price. may this be our last stroller buy. please.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Awesome - I am so saving this for the future kiddos. I am going to be like a mad woman trying to figure out which stroller would be best, so this is perfection.

    ReplyDelete
  15. We are pregnant with #3 and have nothing left from the first two (a move cross country/my husband's common sense prevented my hoarding nature from taking it all along). Things have changed since #1 where all of our hardgoods were from, so this is informative. I have a hard time paying a lot of money for a stroller because we do have a vehicle that we use. I feel like if we were in the city like you it would totally make sense, but North Portland is kind of...well maybe it's just me. I don't know. But this is great info for a starting point--thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Can I be a loser and ask how much you're selling the uppababy for? I have no solid idea of where I would put it in our little ny apartment, but now that you've just made me feel I can fit more children than I would ever have into it at once without taking up the entire sidewalk I'm feeling tempted.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ariella, we're hoping to sell it (plus rumbleseat, rideboard, and rain covers for all) for $250!

      Delete
    2. Natalie!

      I wish I had known about this 2 months ago! We live in the ues and I just had my first 5 weeks ago. We went with the vista and got the bassinet stand and that's where she sleeps for now. We have 2 doggies and I love the ability to transfer her from bedroom to stroller when the pups need to go out. You could have saved me hundreds! We do love the vista but I agree that it's pretty wide. I've bumped that sucker a few times.

      Delete
    3. Oh goodness why do you have to be selling it for so cheap? I will confer with the husband and get in touch with you if we decide to buy it off you.

      Delete
  17. I don't know why I am so fascinated with the strollers people love. Actually extend that fascination to all baby products. It is so interesting to me to hear what people love or don't love and why. We have two strollers - a City Mini and the Britax B-Ready. We researched like madmen for both. I don't really feel like I need an umbrella stroller too. The city mini folds up small enough and fast enough (one handed). I also bought a car seat adaptor for it for our second. It's our workhorse and the B-Ready is our cruise ship. We use it for family outings to DC.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I totally agree with you that there is no single perfect stroller! I have four kids and have purchased a new stroller (or four) with each one. I think a little of this is geographically specific. I haven't used an umbrella stroller since Baby #2, when we were living in Spain. (Sidewalks are so tiny and hard-to-navigate there!). But here in the PacificNorthwest, I can't imagine life without my BoB.
    Great, informative review. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  19. We just got the Maclaren Globetrotter -- it's the new-age Volo with reclining positions. It's black and I really, really like it. But my 2 year old doesn't. Ugh. He'd rather walk. We're still keeping it so check it out if you opt to give up the Volo. And I got it from Planet Kids for 15% off post-Christmas deal. Win!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Doh. Also meant to add that we had a Triumph and loved it but then I forgot it on the sidewalk near CPW while packing the kids in the minivan one warm day. I wish you'd been the one to find it. I still look for it when I'm walking around as if I'd notice the one that used to be ours. Oh well.

      Delete
  20. HI!

    Long time reader here, never a post "reply-er" however, I just had to this time.

    A) Thank you for sharing bits of your life, even the tough stuff. You're a strong, brave and inspiring woman!
    B)THANK YOU for this post! I'm expecting my first and I happen to be paving the way for my friends too. Which means, I know nothing about nothing when it comes to baby products. I've been scouring the internet for stroller reviews and opinions but good gracious, there are a MILLION. How does one make a decision? Your post has truly helped me narrow the decision. I just needed some good and honest pros and cons! Plus, as a long-timer of yours, I respect your opinion.
    C) Keep the baby product review a'comin!

    Lindsay

    ReplyDelete
  21. I say go for a maclaren techno XT, it's not much heavier than a volo but has a great sun shade and cosy footmuff that keeps baby warm right up to toddler years. It also reclines for babies and toddler naps, and has decent storage. The handle height is adjustable too, and the wheels are bigger (and better) than a volo. I got mine when my third child was young and cursed myself for not doing it sooner! It also served as a regular bed for my fourth child to nap in!

    ReplyDelete
  22. get a triumph! You'll love it and huck will love the recline. In addition to the triumph we own an uppababy (bought when I assumed we would have a successful second pregnancy, still working on that) a bugaboo frog, a phil and teds explorer, and a bob revolution. I loan them out to friends and family on a revolving basis so I can admire them when I visit their babies :)
    ps - my uppa baby has a foot brake - not sure what year you have but I think in 09' they made the wheel base narrower too.

    ReplyDelete
  23. See Nat, everybody loves your stroller reviews! I have a Techno XT that I love and use all the time. Here in Scotland they sell weights that you clip on the front of your stroller, thus eliminating the mcclaren tip over, which lets be honest we all have done. Just thought I would pass that tip along in case you hadn't seen them.
    http://www.amazon.co.uk/BuggyWeights-BUWE-MB-Buggy-Weights/dp/B000TV11OO/ref=sr_1_1?s=baby&ie=UTF8&qid=1358289988&sr=1-1

    ReplyDelete
  24. I love my first years wave - I think it became this jj cole stroller, which has all the same nifty features but also lets you change the shade cover easily. It is on amazon:

    http://www.amazon.com/JJ-Cole-Broadway-Stroller-Black/dp/B005NPFRPU/ref=sr_1_1?s=baby-products&ie=UTF8&qid=1358289775&sr=1-1&keywords=jj+cole+stroller

    ReplyDelete
  25. thanks for the reviews! i ended up with 3 strollers too! what the heck. i hated them all (eddie bauer travel system & chicco capri) except my cheapo jogging stroller. it's difficult to fold up, but rolls like a dream. next kid (?) i'd probably spring for a more expensive stroller because i didn't realize how much grief they can cause you! for the last year, i mostly push stevie around in one of these:

    http://www.amazon.com/Step2-Push-Around-Buggy-Red/dp/B00000IZEM/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1358290931&sr=8-1&keywords=push+car

    ha!
    http://www.thismomsgonnasnap.com

    ReplyDelete
  26. haha the praying mantis and exorcist references are cracking me up. never did i think a stroller review could be so entertaining.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I have been looking for a guide just such as this ... stroller choosing has been keep me up at nights, so thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  28. i tell everyone i can, "get a maclaren!!!!!!!!" my volo will be buried with me.

    ReplyDelete
  29. OMG... this is an amazing stroller guide. i started with a britax b ready, and i love it... and i think i will love it more if i have another child (hopefully soon!). i like how you can use the carseat for a little baby, and face the toddler away from the little baby :)

    but then my husband bought me a maclaren techno... and this has been my go-to. it is pretty sweet and i don't think i will ever part with it. ever.

    ReplyDelete
  30. I had an uppababy vista and now a bugaboo donkey... I love them both, but there are a lot of things I like better about the uppababy. I always tell people to buy the vista over the chameleon. I think some of your cons have already been addresses in newer uppababy models?

    ReplyDelete
  31. haha you really do seem like a stroller expert! My Blog

    ReplyDelete
  32. We have four strollers too. A super super cheap umbrella, our Orbit travel system, a bob jogging artillery and the Britax b ready. We got the b ready with baby two. We don't use it often, mostly because we live in Texas and drive everywhere. But I think its fabulous, probably too wide for you though :)

    ReplyDelete
  33. Thank you so much for this! I'm a first time mom and I need all the advice I can get regarding strollers, etc. One thing: I just heard that Bugaboo Cameleon strollers sold between Sept. 2009 and June 2012 were recalled along with some Donkeys: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/01/15/bugaboo-recall_n_2480994.html?1358278965&ncid=edlinkusaolp00000009

    Is the Bugaboo 3 in this group? Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  34. I wish I had seen this when my daughter was tiny. I gave myself wrist problems from pushing my Peg Perrigo, which was the worst stroller ever. IT DID NOT STEER. I tried a friend's Maclaren and gasped at how well it turned on a dime.

    I was obsessed with having my baby be able to see me when she was a baby, so I wanted to be able to have her face me or face away. I devoted far too much thought to this issue, only to realize, no she does NOT want to see me when she was about 6 months old, she wanted to see the world! I was a LUNATIC with all of my stroller anxiety!

    ReplyDelete
  35. I don't want to turn this into a situation, but may I bring to light the Mamas & Papas Urbo? Narrower wheel span than any Bugaboo (my #1 spec), better hood, much cheaper, but with the same smooth glidey push and turn-on-a-dime manoeuvrability. It can take a car seat and a bassinet, but the seat reclines fully so is suitable from birth to college, basically. The whole thing is very light. And the design is beautiful, though polarising... people seem to love it or hate it. I love the clean lines. I'm very vain about strollers and I don't feel like a dag pushing this one. The only thing that sucks is the small basket. I swear up and down that this is the only single stroller I'll ever buy... and hell if I'm not going to try and turn it into a double with a Buggypod when the time comes!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Wow that's a very useful and detailed post! Thanks for sharing this with us. :)

    ReplyDelete
  37. Okay, so I'll confess that I didn't take the "pretty pricey" comment seriously until I clicked the link for the Bugaboo... And then I gasped and maybe even swore under my breath. That's a chunk of change for a stroller! It's gorgeous, but wow. Thanks for the reviews!

    ReplyDelete
  38. Hey Nat! Loved the stroller reviews, although I'm pretty boring and got rid of 5/7 strollers!! when I had my third and splurged and bought a $70 Graco literider. I must, must have a cup holder and storage cup for my drink, phone, and keys! So where do you put all that stuff in the strollers that don't have the parent tray? I've always been curious when I see people with the nice strollers where they keep all their stuff! If I lived in the city and walked all day like you do, I'd def own 1-2 of the strollers you have!

    ReplyDelete
  39. Love, Love, Love my CityMini...so easy to maneuver and can fold it up and put in the trunk with 1 hand.
    -ali
    Other baby products I love:
    http://40tasks.blogspot.com/2012/11/baby-products.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I <3 my city mini too - its also really good on public transport in the middle of the city :)

      Delete
  40. I don't know why I found this so interesting, but I did. I have no kids, so no need for a stroller, but I am a bit of a nerd so I liked reading the features... I also caught myself checking out other people's strollers during my lunch break! Normally I observe shoes, but strollers was fun too.

    ReplyDelete
  41. When you live in the city, there are so many situations where one stroller is better than another. I have three and could use two more! I love my side by side double, but a tandem would be better for sqeezibg through shop doors. I never had a stroller with a bassinet atrachment, but always thought they seemed nice. The only problem is fitting them in the apartment!

    ReplyDelete
  42. I wish I had your reviews about strollers 15 months ago before my son was born! I wanted the bugaboo so bad because that was the stroller that had the best reviews but it was way out of our price point. We thought maybe the bob was a great choice until my son's father got the wrong one. It's a HUGE orange jogging stroller. We have a smaller apartment in LA so it takes up a lot of room. We should probably sell it but I'm having a hard time parting with it. Hoarder syndrome? Probably. Living in LA you don't do a whole lot of walking so we got one of those stroller bases where you snap in the car seat. It was horrible. Then on mother's day I was surprised with one of those Chicco Liteway strollers. While it's easy to fold up and it does recline, it's kinda heavy and the sun shield stinks!! I think we may need to splurge on a new stroller thanks to your reviews!!

    xo
    Rachel

    ReplyDelete
  43. How has the phil&teds not been mentioned?! It's our absolute favorite and rides like a dream.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Love this post. We are going for the Britax B Ready for the convenience with more children down the road but we don't live in a city so we don't have to worry about things NYCers have to! Thank goodness. Haha! :)

    Can I be the first to ask, where did you get your sweater?!!! I want!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  45. After reading so many of your posts about NYC sidewalks, I'm dying to know more. What's it really like to live in NYC?! Are people as un-friendly as I read in books? Are there Carrie Bradshaws walking the streets? Here in St. Louis, MO, we can't walk miles because some roads simply don't have sidewalks. Good ol' farm lands! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  46. Hilarious to see your stroller review! I found Natalie's blog after seeing a link on Ohdeedoh 18 months ago about reviews she had done on living-an-urban-life-and-needing-a-great-stroller. Couldn't find the post, exchanged emails with you and it was funny because you hadn't done a review yet! I live in a small apartment in DC and we walk a couple of miles each weekday and several miles on weekends so we needed 1. durability 2. good basket storage and 3. small enough to take on our metro trains w/o getting the horrible stinkeyes from fellow commuters.
    We love the strollers we chose. I really wanted the Uppababy Vista -- so pretty! -- but too expensive so we started with the Graco carseat and paired it with the Snap&Go car seat frame. It was great because even though we don't have a car, we could easily grab a cab for quick doctor's visits or a Zipcar for rides to the Grandparents. It took a little while to get used to the shorter stride so we wouldn't constantly kick the stroller, but you could manipulate the handlebar to help accommodate that AND it drastically minimized the profile when we were in tight spaces (elevators!).
    At about a year, Charlie outgrew the carseat and we switched to a hand-me-down Maclaren umbrella (I think it was the Triumph) full-time (first started using it around 6months) but it was too short (my husband and I are 6ft tall/taller), the brakes were hard to kick on, you kind of had to lift Charlie's tush to get anything in the basket, Charlie sat pretty low so you couldn't use the BundleMe w/o it dragging on the street. We bought the Uppababy G-Luxe and love it! It's taller for us, Charlie sits higher (thereby not ruining our oh-so-cozy BundleMe), it's a better (not great) basket, the brakes are straight-forward (but one did just break this week after one year of VERY heavy use) and it collapses easily. The trickiest part is opening it after it's been collapsed, but if you read the reviews online, you figure it out quickly. It's fair to say that I agonized about all of our stroller decisions and I feel really great about where we ended up. Hope this helps someone!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just a quick update: I emailed Uppababy that same day and they sent out replacement wheels right away!

      Delete
  47. Ooh, I like reviews!
    We live in central London and I've found that for us the combo that works is the City Mini Baby Jogger for when we're walking around town / catching the bus (it's light, has great manoeuvrability and the one handed fold is awesome - plus it's way cheaper than the bugaboo etc) and then babywearing (with a moby and now a didymos wrap) for anytime I need to use the Underground (so so SO much easier on escalators/stairs than a pushchair!)
    Now G is a toddler though, I think we may need to invest in an umbrella stroller..

    Thanks for the tips
    P

    ReplyDelete
  48. I have the Britax B-Ready and I hate how wide the wheel base is. I think it's comparable to the Vista. I was not stroller shopping until I saw this. Now I *need* an umbrella stroller.
    The choosing of the stroller was by far the most stressful decision and purchase when I was pregnant with #1. I put so much effort into it and still got it wrong!

    ReplyDelete
  49. Why am I so enthralled with this post?! I'm nowhere near having babies!!

    ReplyDelete
  50. We have the BOB and the City Micro. We love them both, although you can really tell that the BOB is built to last compared to the Micro. I think that if we ever need a double stroller, I'll get the City Mini Double. For a side-by-side double, it's amazingly narrow.

    ReplyDelete
  51. we have one stroller. it rarely gets used (we live in suburbia) and it's a graco. as much as i'd love to splurge on a prettier stroller, the one we have really works great! have you tried the orbit? that's the one i wanted!

    ReplyDelete
  52. This is funny! I never thought about needing more than one stroller :)

    ReplyDelete
  53. did you hear the bugaboo cameleon got recalled? not sure if its the same one you have, but i just saw this... http://www.cpsc.gov/cpscpub/prerel/prhtml13/13092.html

    http://www.thismomsgonnasnap.com

    ReplyDelete
  54. I liked the blog and loved the way you described the strollers, however I think that calling a $300 stroller cheap is a little I don't know...I can't even find the right word. I don't want to be offensive because I absolutely do not mean it that way. I just think that a lot of average families who don't live in cities and don't use their stroller every single time they venture out don't spend quite that much on strollers. Much less people without a lot of extra money to spend. I just think the review was a little slanted towards city livers without vehicles and those that can easily drop $300 on a stroller and call it cheap.

    ReplyDelete
  55. We're about to have a baby and this was so reaffirming - we've had our eyes on the cameleon after researching everything out there! thanks so much for the run-down! even my husband read this post :)

    http://theyorksgreatadventure.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  56. I am the worst at making decisions (what if I make the wrong one?!) and, being in the market for a new stroller, am not loving the fact that you say there is no such thing as a perfect stroller. I know you're right, but that is not what I wanted to hear. I'm sure I'll figure out what's best for me and my babe (possibly hundreds of dollars and multiple strollers) sooner or later. Thanks for the pro's and con's of these ones. This definitely helps.

    ReplyDelete
  57. If you love the Volo, you should check out the UppaBaby GLite (since you obv need a 5th stroller!). It changed my life. And we just took it on a month-long backpacking trip through SE Asia with our 2 yr old and it saved us.
    Thanks for the review!

    http://ultraeden.wordpress.com/

    ReplyDelete
  58. I know Im late to the party (I just stumbled upon this post) but I totally get it!! I took 8 weeks to pick a stroller and I still want another one so we can have 2. My family thinks Im crazy. I just got a gently used Bugaboo Bee via craigslist (I love Craigslist!!) and I really want to craigslist myself a Cameleon for when we go camping or to the Beach, ect. I get it girl!!

    ReplyDelete
  59. I think you have an older Uppababy. The wheels in your apartment photo are giant and much different from the current model (shown in the body of the post). If you try out a newer or current model, your cons may change.

    ReplyDelete
  60. I wish I could find the First Years Wave somewhere! It's not available on Amazon anymore :( Thank you for this stroller guide! Gives me bad stroller envy - we just have a $10 cheapo umbrella stroller, and definitely need an upgrade!

    ReplyDelete
  61. I'm with Julie! I can't find the First Years Wave anywhere either! Are you still selling your uppababy, or has it been sold? If not, please email me! amlopac(at)gmail(dot)com I'd have to talk with my husband, but if it's still for sale, we may be interested!

    ReplyDelete

« »

NAT THE FAT RAT All rights reserved © Blog Milk Powered by Blogger